Documents

Introduction

Transactional Documents

Selective Documents

Memo for the Record

Maps

Chronological Order

Documentation

Project Blue Book Termination

Project Blue Book Termination

In December 1969, Secretary of the Air Force, Robert C. Seamans, Jr., announced the termination of the USAF program for the investigation of unidentified flying objects, stating that “the continuation of Project Blue Book cannot be justified either on the ground of national security or in the interest of science,” while concluding that the project does not merit future expenditures of resources.

Following the announcement, Blue Book staff delivered the administrative and case files for approximately 13,000 UFO sighting reports (1947-69) to the Air Force Archives at Maxwell AFB, Alabama, where the records were available upon request until 1975. Subsequently, the records were microfilmed by the Air Force before transfer to the National Archives and Record Administration (NARA) in Washington, D.C. NARA produced its 35mm microfilm version [NARA Microfilm Publication T1206] for public release in 1976.[1]

The 24 October 1968 Minot AFB case file number is 12,548. The documents comprise 145 pages in chronological order from 24 October to 14 November 1968, including two maps, and thirteen B-52 radarscope photographs.


Transactional Documents

The bulk of the documents are transactional records, compliant to the procedures promulgated by Air Force Regulation No. 80-17, which established the overall objectives and uniform responsibilities of the UFO program.[2] Under the general provisions of AFR 80-17, each commander at an Air Force base was required to provide a UFO investigative capability. In this instance, Minot AFB commander Colonel Ralph E. Kirchoff designated 862nd Combat Support Group, Operations Division chief Lt. Colonel Arthur J. Werlich as liaison to the UFO project. This was Werlich's first UFO investigation, and he initially contacted Strategic Air Command headquarters, Offutt AFB, Neb, to request technical assistance, but was directed by Col. Weyant in Operations to comply strictly with AFR 80-17. Werlich's primary responsibility was to collect and collate a formatted list of Basic Reporting Data, to include his initial analysis and comments on the possible cause or stimulus for the observation at the end of the report.

During the course of collecting the data, apparently Werlich interviewed 17 witnesses who visually observed a UFO, of which only 7 completed the 9-page Air Force Form 117, Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire (AF-117).

Once Werlich had collated the Basic Reporting Data, he electronically transmitted the 8-page report to designated Air Force agencies, including Blue Book in the Foreign Technology Division (FTD) at Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio.[3] Upon receipt, Blue Book staff were required to evaluate the information in order to determine a cause or stimulus for the reports and produce a final case report.

These primary transactional documents total 83 pages.


Selective Documents

Following receipt of the Basic Reporting Data, Blue Book staff requested supplemental information and specific materials to be forwarded by mail. In response, Werlich sent several selective documents that had been recorded concurrent with the events, which preserve and communicate to others descriptions of what was happening at a given time. These documents include an upper-air rawinsonde dataset;[4] a two-hour sequential log of the UFO descriptions and movements reported to the Base Operations Dispatcher by the ground observers at N-7; a witness list with sighting times, which includes a summary of distinct events compiled by the 91st Missile Wing, Security Controller; a Transcription of Recorded Conversations between Radar Approach Control (RAPCON) and the B-52 co-pilot; and a sequence of thirteen 8x10" photographic prints of the B-52 radarscope film.

These selective documents total 19 pages.


Memo for the Record

During the course of the investigation, Blue Book staff were in regular contact with Col. Werlich and transcripts of the telephone conversations are included as Memo(s) for the Record. These documents provide supplemental information, and moreover, in contrast to the formality of the transactional documents, personal details, and insight into the process of the investigation. Included are Werlich's initial report to Blue Book; requests from Blue Book staff for additional information and materials following receipt of the Basic Reporting Data; Werlich's response to the requests; and two subsequent requests by Blue Book assistant Lieutenant Marano for information concerning the weather radar that were ultimately not responded to.

Further, there are 3 Memo(s) for the Record, and two TWX communications between Strategic Air Command headquarters and Blue Book staff. Monday morning following the events, Colonel Weyant, in the Directorate of Operations at SAC, phoned twice inquiring about Blue Book investigation procedures. And later, Colonel Pullen, assistant to the Deputy Chief of Staff Intelligence, Brig. General Richard R. Stewart, was in periodic contact with Blue Book chief Lt. Colonel Hector Quintanilla.

These memorandum of communications comprise 20 pages.

Project Blue Book Staff

Maps

Werlich also prepared and forwarded a map overlay (transparency to be superimposed on a 200-series map chart), in which he plotted the B-52 movements during the UFO encounters, including the relative positions and movements of the UFO. Due to security restrictions, he could not forward the original 200-series map chart (1:200,000), but instead, instructed Blue Book staff to acquire the original master chart at Wright-Patterson AFB. Whether Blue Book staff did is not known, particularly since the map included in the file is an unclassified Off-base Disaster Control Grid Map with a different scale (1:250,000).[5]


Chronological Order

No. Title Description Date Pp. Seq.
1.pdfFile folder"Minot AFB, ND 24 October 1968"11
2.pdfCover page"Minot AFB, ND 24 October 1968 Air & Ground-Visual, Air Radar."12
3.pdfFile index card"Project 10073 Record." 13
4.pdfSeparator page"This case includes 13 photos 8 X 10."14
5.pdfMemo for the Record"Subject: UFO Observation, Minot AFB, North Dakota, 24 October 1968" Late Thursday afternoon, Col. Werlich phoned Blue Book to report the UFO events per AFR 80-17.24 October 196826
6.pdfMemo for the Record"SUBJECT: 24 Oct 68 UFO Sighting from Minot AFB N.D."
Late Monday morning, Col. Weyant in Operations at SAC headquarters phoned Blue Book duty officer Sgt. Jones inquiring about the UFO report.
28 October 1968a17
7.pdfMemo for the Record"Subj: Call fm Col Wyatt, SAC Hqs"
Early Monday afternoon, Col. Weyant in Operations at SAC headquarters phoned Blue Book assistant Lt. Marano inquiring about the UFO investigation.
28 October 1968b18
8.pdfBasic Reporting Data (TWX)"SUBJ: UFO REPORT"
Prepared by 862nd CSG Operations Div. Chief (designated Project Blue Book investigating officer), Arthur J. Werlich, Lt Col, Minot AFB NDAK, containing specific responses to Basic Reporting Data required by AFR 80-17. Transmitted to ADC at Ent AFB, CO; WIADIV Malmstrom AFB, MT; FTD at Wright-Patterson AFB, OH; AFRDC; and SAF-OI.
290428Z 28 October 10:28 p.m. (CST)816
9.pdfMemo for the Record"Subject: UFO Sighting, 24 Oct 68, Minot AFB"
Tuesday morning, Lt. Marano phoned Minot AFB and spoke to Mr. Carber about the status of Werlich's UFO report.
29 October 1968117
10.pdfMemo for the Record"Subj: Telephone conversation with Col Pullen, Hq SAC"
Tuesday afternoon, Blue Book chief Col. Quintanilla phones Col. Pullen at HQ SAC. who requests a preliminary report for DCS/I Gen. Stewart "to get this thing simmered down."
30 October 1968a118
11.pdfMemo for the Record"Subj: Need for Additional Info on Minot Sightings"
Wednesday morning, Lt. Marano phoned Minot AFB requesting that Col. Werlich obtain the following supplemental information and forward it to Blue Book.
30 October 1968b220
12.pdfMemo for the Record"Subj: Telephone conversation of 31 Oct 68, Col Werlich - Lt Marano"
Thursday afternoon, Col. Werlich phoned Lt. Marano in response to his request for supplemental information on the Minot observations.
01 November 1968a727
13.pdfMemo for the Record"Talked to Mr. Goff, TDPA, who is quite familiar with air-borne radars." On Thursday Goff suggested to Quintanilla that the observations "may have been precipitated by some type of ionized plasma similar to ball lightning."01 November 1968b128
14.pdfUpper-air data set(Unreadable).
A complete National Climatic Data Center dataset for 0000 and 1200 hrs., 24 Oct. 1968, Bismarck, ND, is included in the Shough Report.
See: Endnote #10.
129
15.pdfWing Security Controller's summary"On 24 Oct 68 the following personnel at the listed LCF's sited the UFO at times indicated."
The 91st Strategic Missile Wing security controller's list of UFO observers, and brief summary of events.
130
16.pdfBase Operations Dispatcher's log."0800. Object S/E of N-7 moving towards site with brilliant light like the sun."
Base Operations Dispatcher's chronological log of UFO events reported by ground observers at N-7, from 0800-1010Z (3:00-5:10 a.m. CDT).
131
17.pdfTranscription of Recorded Conversations"Transcript of tape for 24 Oct 68 from 0830 to 0915"
Transcript with time-code references of conversations between the B-52 co-pilot (Runyon) and ground controller's at Minot AFB, Radar Approach Control (RAPCON), from 3:44-4:40 a.m. CDT.
334
18.pdfAF Form 117A1C Isley, Lloyd M. (91st MIMS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
28 October 1968943
19.pdfAF Form 117A1C O'Connor, Robert Micheal (91st MIMS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
28 October 1968952
20.pdfAF Form 117A1C Jablonski, Joseph Patrick (862nd SPS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
25 October 1968961
21.pdfAF Form 117A1C Adams, Gregory (862nd SPS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
25 October 1968970
22.pdfAF Form 117SSgt. Bond, James Frederick (FSC - 862nd SPS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
26 October 1968979
23.pdfAF Form 117SSgt. Smith, William E., Jr. (FSC - 862nd SPS)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
26 October 1968988
24.pdfAF Form 117Maj. Partin, James A. (Pilot - 23rd Bomb Sq., 5th BMW)
"Sighting of Unidentified Phenomena Questionnaire"
30 October 1968997
25.pdfTWX"TO COL PULLEN SSO SAC. FROM LT COL QUINTANILLA REFERENCE OUR TELECON WITH REGARDS TO MINOT AFB UFO'S."O12014Z
01 November
8:14 p.m. (EST)
198
26.pdfTWX"REFERENCE OUR TDPT MESSAGE REGARDING MINOT AFB UFO. SAC COMMANDER AND STAFF ARE EXTREMELY INTERESTED IN THIS ITEM."O71540Z
07 November
3:40 p.m. (EST)
199
27.pdfMemo
for the Record
"Subj: Minot AFB Sightings"
Lt. Marano wanted to ask Werlich about the weather radar.
08 November 19681100
28.pdfProject Blue Book Final Report"UFO Observation, 24 October 1968"
"The following conclusions have been reached after a thorough study of the data submitted to the Foreign Technology Division." This one-page letter with three attachments was sent to the Special Security Office at SAC headquarters; with copies to the 862nd CSG, Minot AFB, ND; and SAF-OI.
13 November 196812112
29.pdfMemo
for the Record
"Subject: Telephone call of 13 Nov 68 to Minot AFB, North Dakota"
Blue Book staff called Col. Werlich to request information on the weather radar.
14 November 19681113
30.pdfWerlich Overlay MapOverlay map (transparency) prepared by Col. Werlich based on a classified USAF series-200 map, providing the flight track of the B-52 and relative locations of the UFO (1:200,000).7120
31.pdfMinot
area map
OFF-BASE DISASTER CONTROL GRID MAP (9 November 1965)
(1:250,000).
12132
32.pdf 13 Radarscope PhotographsThirteen 8 X 10 photographs of the B-52 ASQ-38 radar Plan Position Indicator (PPI) with data plates, from the Maxwell/NARA microfilm. These images are very poor quality reproductions.24 October 196813145